Copyright Law

COPYRIGHT DEFENSES: No Infringement Defense (Independent Creation)

February 15, 2011

Two computer programs can be identical and yet there will be no copyright infringement if both were created independently of each other. One common way of doing this is by creating a “clean room.”

Timothy B. McCormack, lawyer in Seattle, writes: One may independently develop a competing program by having a first team produce design documentation of inputs and desired outputs after lawfully analyzing a first program from which the competing program is to be developed. A second team then writes code for the competing program based on the created design documentation. The competing program, even if substantially similar to the first program will not likely infringe any copyrights because of its independent creation.

Read the full article →

COPYRIGHT DEFENSES: Expired Copyrights and Public Domain (The Public Owns it Now)

February 14, 2011

Timothy B. McCormack, attorney and founder of McCormack Intellectual Property Law PS writes: Two computer programs can be identical and yet there will be no copyright infringement if both were created independently of each other. One common way of doing this is by creating a “clean room.”

Read the full article →

COPYRIGHT DEFENSES

February 10, 2011

Timothy B. McCormack, attorney and copyright lawyer, writes: Even if one establishes ownership in a copyrighted work and that an accused infringer copied the work, the accused infringer may escape liability under one of several defenses set forth in the Copyright Act. Note, however, that although a defense to copyright infringement may exist, one may still be prohibited from copying a work. Some defenses are absolute, and thus one can copy with impunity (assuming of course that the defense can be proven at trial). Other defenses can shield one from the legal consequences of copying another work, however, they are sometimes difficult to prove. In cases where the copying is exact – like I copied 100% of your image, picture or photograph there is typically no good defense – copyright in those cases are strict liability torts.

Read the full article →

COPYRIGHT DEFENSES: Governmental Works

February 9, 2011

Timothy B. McCormack, lawyer, writes: Works of authorship by the United States Government are not subject to copyright.(66) A “work of the United States Government” is defined as “a work prepared by an officer or employee of the United States Government as part of their official duties.”

Read the full article →

AVOIDING COPYRIGHT INFRINGEMENT IN THE REALM OF SOFTWARE DEVELOPMENT: Other Copyrighted Material

February 8, 2011

Timothy B. McCormack, attorney at law and Seattle copyright lawyer, has been writing about how not to infringe copyrights for years: One should presume that all postings on the Internet are copyrighted unless specifically stated otherwise or unless the postings fall into one of the categories of uncopyrightable material discussed below. Postings that are presumably copyrighted include: (1) email, (2) Usenet and news group posting, (3) bulletin board system (BBS) posting, (4) mailing lists posting, (5) postings to Internet Service Providers (such as America Online and Microsoft Network), (6) interactive chat communications (IRC), (7) recordings of communications via Internet telephone and Internet video conferencing, (8) web page contents, (9) computer graphics, (10) sound, (11) video; and, of course, (12) photographs.

Read the full article →

AVOIDING COPYRIGHT INFRINGEMENT IN THE REALM OF SOFTWARE DEVELOPMENT: Reverse Engineering/Decompilation

February 3, 2011

Timothy B. McCormack, attorney at law, writes: Reverse engineering can be accomplished in at least two ways.(60) First, one may reverse engineer a program through the program’s design documentation. For example, one may independently develop a competing program by having one team produce design documentation of desired inputs and outputs after lawfully analyzing the program from which the competing program is to be developed. Another team then writes codes for the competing program based on the created design documentation.

Read the full article →